87. Good Masters! Sweet Ladies!
Good Masters! Sweet Ladies! Voices from a Medieval Village by Laura Amy SchlitzIllustrated by Robert Byrd
Pages: 81
Finished: May 14, 2008
First Published: 2007
Genre: historical fiction, non-fiction, play, children
Rating: 2/5
Reason for Reading: This is last year's Newbery winner and I am reading all the Newberys.
First sentence:
The Feast of All Souls, I ran from my tutor -
Latin and grammar - no wonder!
Comments: A collection of monologues/soliloquies written to be performed by middle grade students. Each monologue tells the tale of an individual child from the middle ages. Footnotes are presented in sidebars and a few non-fiction factual pieces explain various medieval customs and history. The book is gorgeously illustrated with medieval-type illustrations in ink and watercolour. The design of the book is also very visually pleasing with coloured ribbon sidebars on every page.
While I found this book very pretty, the text did nothing for me. The majority of the monologues are written in verse (some even rhyming) which was very tedious to read and frankly, boring. I can't imagine watching a play that consists of a bunch of monologues to be very entertaining either. I enjoy both historical fiction and books that take place in the middle ages but this book was just not my thing.
I'm reading this one with my girls right now, and I have to say it's pretty slow going! We're doing one or two characters a night, and they're mildly interested and are learning a lot about life during that time. I doubt this one would be on a list of favorites chosen by kids.
ReplyDelete**I doubt this one would be on a list of favorites chosen by kids.**
ReplyDeleteMy thought exactly!